Under the Aged Care Act 2024, every older person is presumed able to make their own decisions, and supported decision-making in aged care means giving them help to do so when they want or need it. Most care plans record what a person chose. Few record how much of the decision the person wants to make themselves, or who they want involved.
This article sets out a simple decision-making preference record that fills that gap. It is good practice we recommend, not a form taken from the Act.
Key Takeaways
- The Department of Health, Disability and Ageing says every older person is presumed able to make their own decisions, and that this applies to each new decision.
- A registered supporter helps a person make and communicate their own decisions. They cannot decide for the person unless they also hold legal authority, such as guardianship or an enduring power of attorney.
- Two questions need separate answers: what does the person want, and how much of the decision do they want to make themselves?
- A preference record works best when reviewed at change points such as hospital discharge, a new diagnosis or a change in who supports the person.
- Department guidance lists what to note about a decision: who was present, supports used, options explained, the person's own words, disagreements and concerns.
What does supported decision-making mean under the Aged Care Act 2024?
The Department describes supported decision-making as support that helps older people make and communicate their own decisions and stay in control of their lives. The Department's registered supporter information adds that having a supporter does not stop a person dealing directly with their provider.
The Department's capacity policy notes that the Act does not use the phrase "presumption of capacity" for older people, but says the presumption is embedded in the Act, including in the Statement of Rights. It also says ability can fluctuate, so a person who cannot decide on one occasion should not be excluded from the next decision. These principles apply whether or not the person has a registered supporter. Your dignity and choice policy should say so, and workers should know the Statement of Rights obligations include being supported to decide.
Why record how much say a person wants, not just what they choose?
Two people can make the same choice and want different roles in making it. One wants the options and decides alone. Another wants a daughter present and the doctor's recommendation first. A record of the choice alone cannot tell a new worker which applies.
Research supports asking rather than assuming. A 2026 PLOS One study by Steel, Zaninotto, Enwo and Banks analysed the English Longitudinal Study of Ageing, a UK survey of 6,098 people aged 50 and over living in private households in England. Participants aged over 75 were more likely than younger ones to want to leave treatment decisions to a doctor, and women were less likely than men to want to delegate. The authors found preferences varied widely and concluded that age and sex patterns cannot replace asking individuals. It is a UK sample, so treat it as a reason to ask, not a rule.
Who can support a decision, and who can make it?
The Act separates these roles, and your records should too. Department guidance describes three:
- The person themselves: presumed able to decide, with or without support.
- A registered supporter: chosen by the person to help them make and communicate decisions. Supporters must promote the person's wishes and preferences, and support them only as much as needed so they keep their decision-making ability.
- An appointed decision-maker: someone with guardianship, an enduring power of attorney or similar legal authority, who may decide only within that active authority.
The substitute decision-making post covers when an appointed decision-maker steps in, and our registered supporters and consent post covers home services. A relative who visits often is not automatically either role. Record who holds which role and where the evidence sits. If a state or territory instrument is unclear, confirm with your own legal adviser.
What goes in a decision-making preference record?
This is good practice, not a legal requirement. Keep it short enough that a care worker reads it before a conversation, and use the person's own words where possible.
- Decision areas: daily routine, services and schedule, finances, medication, treatment and health appointments, where they live.
- Preferred role for each area: decide alone, decide with support, hear the clinician's recommendation first, or ask someone else to lead. This is the "how much say" answer.
- People they want involved, with their role: registered supporter, appointed decision-maker, or family or friend with no formal role. Also note anyone they do not want involved.
- How they like to receive information: plain language, an interpreter, written summaries, extra time, hearing or vision supports.
- Date, who recorded it and the review date.
How should medication and treatment decisions fit in?
Treatment decisions sit between the person and their treating clinicians. Your role is to record the person's preferred role, make sure clinicians can see it, and escalate to the prescriber or clinical lead when wishes are unclear or change. Link the record to your consent for medication policy.
Where does dignity of risk come in?
Department guidance says older people have the right to take personal risks, and that a decision should not be set aside only because someone disagrees or it carries risk. Record the risk discussion, the supports offered and the person's decision. Your dignity of risk policy should point to this record.
When should you review the record, and what if family disagree?
Because ability and wishes can change, set review points. Good practice triggers include:
- Hospital discharge, when a person may be tired, unwell or newly reliant on others.
- A new diagnosis, including dementia, stroke or a progressive condition.
- A change in supporter or decision-maker, such as a new registration or guardianship order.
- A move or change of services, and any update to advance care planning.
For disagreement, the Department's quick reference suggests asking the person who they want involved, confirming each role, and redirecting to the person if a supporter answers first. It then suggests parking the argument, reconfirming the person's own decision, and engaging the supporter in a conversation focused on that decision.
It also lists warning signs: a supporter speaking over the person, refusing a private check-in, or a person who goes quiet when the supporter is present. The response is pause, separate, escalate and document. If the person needs help to be heard, your advocacy and access policy should explain how to offer an independent advocate.
What evidence shows supported decision-making is happening?
Department guidance says a decision record should note who was present, the supports provided, the options explained, the decision in the person's own words, how any disagreement was handled, and any concerns and action taken. The Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission is the national regulator, and your policies should be consistent with the obligations it publishes.
As good practice, keep these where an assessor can find them quickly:
- Preference records for a sample of people, with review dates met.
- Decision notes showing the person's role, not only the outcome.
- Role evidence: supporter registration details and copies of legal authority.
- Training records showing workers know supporting from substituting.
Governa Connect maps an organisation's policies to the Strengthened Aged Care Quality Standards, Norma answers staff questions grounded in the organisation's own policies, and Governa publishes free policy templates.
Ask the person, then write it down
The Act starts from the person's own voice, so your records should too. Asking what someone wants is not enough; ask how much of the decision they want to make and who they want beside them. Start by adding one "preferred role" line to your next care plan review and test it with five people.
Related Resources
- Advance care planning policy template
- Consent for medication policy template
- Dignity of risk and positive risk-taking policy
- When substitute decision-making applies in aged care
- Map your policies to the Strengthened Quality Standards
- Department quick reference on working with registered supporters
Common Questions About Supporting People to Make Their Own Decisions
1. Does a person need a registered supporter for supported decision-making?
No. The Department's quick reference says supported decision-making principles and processes do not depend on a person having a registered supporter. Providers and workers should apply them whether or not one is present.
2. Can a registered supporter make decisions for the person?
In general, no. The Department says a registered supporter helps the person make and communicate their own decisions. They can decide for the person only if they also have legal authority, such as guardianship or an enduring power of attorney, and then only within that authority.
3. What should we do if family disagree with the person's decision?
Reconfirm the person's own decision and keep the conversation focused on it. If you see warning signs, pause, separate, escalate and document how the person's choice was confirmed.
4. How often should we review a decision-making preference record?
We have not found a review frequency set by the Act, so this is good practice. Review at change points such as hospital discharge, a new diagnosis or a change in supporter, and at each scheduled care plan review. The Department notes ability can fluctuate, so ask again when circumstances change.
5. Can we assume an older person wants the doctor to decide?
No. A 2026 UK study found people over 75 were more likely to want a doctor to decide, but the authors stress that preferences varied widely and cannot replace asking each person. Ask, record the answer and let the clinician see it.





